Thursday, June 4, 2009

Another All-Star Bites the Dust

First it was Brian Giles, then Aramis Ramirez and Kenny Lofton. Both with mixed reactions and results. The Ramirez and Lofton trade brought back the Pirates a second basemen with a baseball IQ below the mendoza line and a bag peanuts. Who am I to argue, I like peanuts. But the Giles trade brought us back 2 all-star calliber players in Oliver Perez and Jason Bay. Ollie started to fizzle so the Pirates ousted him, but Bay...oh Bay; He was a different story. He was our All-star. He became the face of the franchise for a short while averaging about 30 Hr's and 100 RBI's a season while he donned a Pirates uni. However as we all know, Bay along with Nady (who both had another year on their contract left) were traded with Damaso Marte to the Red Sox and Yankees Respectively, to trim payroll and get rid of the head ache of having to shell over multiple millions of dollars to a couple guys who would certainly be worth the money the Pirates cannot afford to give, to bolster a weak minor league system with a few prospects. In my opinion at least one of those prospects seems like he may work out in Andy LaRoche, who is hitting .300, and has an OBP around .370. Both respectible, but a little more power (2 HR's all season) couldn't hurt. Jose Tabata seems like a ligitimate future star, but he still has a couple of years to grow, Hanson needs to learn some control, that and get healthy, and I'm still in the wait and see mode for Moss, who I think was the worthless piece thrown in, but I digress. The trade has been OK, for the Pirates, it was a complete failure for the Yankees (haha!), but it has been Gold for the Red Sox and Jay-Bay who is making a run at making it back-to-back seasonal MVP's for the Red Sox Affiliate.

The first major move by Huntington and Company, had most everyone in Pittsburgh second guessing his scouting savvy. His managerial prowess of assessing the future stars for the franchise from players still in professional diapers spitting up on themselves, gurgling, and doing it all over again and calling it progress, has most of us scratching our heads. But, we give him the benefit of the doubt because it doesn't seem as if he's trying to make progress for progresses sake. Maybe it's because he looks so much like the kid on MAD magazine that we look the other way when he starts analyzing the trade market or available free agents (craig monroe?). Or, it could've been the contract extensions he gave to the Pirates "Core" Players four months ago, that we all figured Hunt and Co. are headed in the right direction and have the right idea for the future of the currently miserable franchise.

Signing Ryan Doumit and Paul Maholm were big deals for us. It signalled the end of a losing era, the beginning of a bright future from 2 above average players who were ready to take one more step to start calling themselves all-stars. Hell, even fantasy experts started to agree with that assessment, ranking Ryan Doumit in the top 8 of catchers and maholm, well maholm didn't get the best ranking #81 for starting pitchers, but he was the best ranked pirates pitcher since Jason Schmidt. Then just when there was a peep of rejoicing the Pirates signed Nate "the great" McClouth to a multi-year deal and solidifying him as the face of our franchise and my peep upgraded to a hollow belch. His ranking was in the top 15 of outfielders, ranking him ahead of ichiro, crawford, upton, abreu, etc., and make people (me especially) to start praising the work of the Pirates front office and can't wait to see what will happen after we get that 17th consecutive losing season(you all know it was going to happen regardless). I was thinking .500 was right around the corner in 2010, the playoffs in 2012 and beyond. But, my burping parade was smothered with a fistful of lemons and my hopes of a .500 season dashed as I can faintly hear Queen's "Another One Bites the Dust" as an anthem towards the remainder of the Pirates season after Hunt n Co. traded away "...your best all around player..." as stated by Pirates shortstop Jack Wilson.

Gorkys Hernandez, Charlie Morton, Jeff Locke...say hello to your 2011 Pittsburgh Pirates! Atleast thats when they are projected to POSSIBLY make a difference in our franchise. Gorkys Ma-Morkys is playing very well in Double A ball and was the Braves number 4 ranked prospect. Locke, the 7th ranked prospect out of the Braves system, is kind of struggling in A ball, but is left handed, so that makes him valuable despite his 5+ ERA and his worse than 2-1 strike out to walk ratio (43 K's/26 BB's) . Morton is another story all together. He wasn't even ranked, but he is dominating triple A and should be seen in a pirates uniform in the coming month, barring any injury. He's got the frame of a pitcher at 6'4", and throws a mid-90's fastball and is crushing triple A hitters with a 7-2 record, 2.51 ERA and 55 K's to 16 BB's. He's 25, so he's in that stage where he's still young but his window of opportunity is closing. Not as quickly as the Pirates 2009 season, but still it's not as bright as it used to be.

Now, I have to question...Why even give Nate that extension if you were just going to trade him away? It's not as if the Pirates aren't financially stable that we have to unload contract after contract. The front office has been making strides in so many directions. They have invested in expanding over seas, have been building a brand new training facility in the dominican, have shown us how eager they are to put a winning product in the most beautiful stadium in baseball. Why then would they put so much of pittsburgh.500 baseball hope on Nates slender 5'11" frame only to give it away to the team who is so good at destroying pittsburgh baseball dreams (NLCS '91&'92). I can't help but invision Nate making the game winning slide in the bottom of the 9th inning mirroring Sid Bream's gloriously mocking smile as Nate hands us our 82nd loss of the 2009 season and once again dashes my pittsburgh baseball hopes and dreams and for the 17th time in 17 years I toast to the future of my God-Damned Pirates Baseball team, always to the future, never to the next series or the next game as it should, always to the future. I give my silent toast, raise my empty Iron City can, strike up the band and turn up the volume on "::bum:: ::bum:: ::bum:: ::ah:: Another one Bites the Dust!"

Gotta love that Pirates baseball!

12 comments:

Ngewo said...

The Pirates gave Nate the extension because they truly believed they were going to keep him. However, when a trade comes around that is something you want, you have to take it. Yes, the Pirates did not get Tommy Hanson, but Gorkeys looks like another Tabata, young/super talented, just very unseasoned.

If there was any belief that Nate would be here for years, then you are sadly mistaken. If McCutch does well when he comes up, then what did it hurt to trade Nate?

Also, many scouts do not think Nate will produce the numbers he did last year. His projected stats usually have him around 21 HRs (I know, you believe him to be the next Bonds), so what will it hurt us if this year or next year he regresses back and Gorkeys ends up stealing 112 bases for the bases and hitting .375? Okay, I just like a guy named Gorkeys...

Don't get me wrong, I am said to see Nate go, but the Pirates have to continue doing the unpopular things if they want to compete in the future. Hopefully they can get enough solid players that maybe a trade will happen where we get a David Price type pitcher...one can dream.

The Gideon said...

lol, you silly Pirates. They obviously are the last thing on my mind, but I couldn't help but chuckle and think of the pancake when I heard the news.

Oh, and the only people that think PNC is the greatest park out there are those that haven't been to Yankee Stadium v 2.0

J Offord said...

My initial reaction when I saw the banner on ESPN that Nate was traded was shock and anger. I was very close to buying the black alternate McClouth jersey, so I would have been quite upset had I done so. I was even more upset after hearing who we got in return, which did not seem like much. Day 1 of the post-Nate trade was not a good one.

But, it slowly sank in that 1) McClouth is not a franchise player like Bay was, and he was certainly expendable.
2) Nate will never have another season like last year, especially considering his age (see my past post about this).
3) The prospects aren't THAT bad, and after reading Huntington's letter I am fairly convinced it was the right thing to do.

I agree with Josh that the Pirates did not intend on trading him unless something came along that exceeded their expectations, and according to the brass, this did. However, the new team of scouts have not brought in any convincing talent yet, so I am skeptical. Karstens and Ohlendorff aren't showing much at this point, Lil' LaRoche is a capable bat for second base, but not 3B. Moss' ceiling is average at best, and no one else has shown much promise yet.

However, McCutch had to be a key part of the decision because he is obviously ready for the bigs. I am excited to see him play for almost an entire season.

Overall, I am torn between the trade. Sure, I am not sad to see Nate go, but I think we could have held off until the trade deadline and got a ton more for him. Just my opinion though.

Anonymous said...

I agree the Pirates weren't planning on trading nate. They don't "plan" on trading any of the more talented diamonds in the rough. They made a baseball decision, based off the fact they believed the organization received more than what management believed was acceptable for a player of nates caliber. My biggest concern, tracing back to the earliest PNC Park days is, Pirates management never receives Major League proven talent. I know it's always a luck of the draw and that's why you pay scouts to find undaunted prospect talent, but it would have been nice to receive a player who has more Major league games under their belt than Nyjer Morgan has home runs.

As it goes, I don't think I'm just ready to grade this trade as a failure until I see what Gorkys has to offer. That won't be until mid-season of next year, more than likely the start of 2011, but we will see how he progresses. So, this trade does offer a glimmer of hope i think.

As it goes for Nate not going to have the season he had last year. His power numbers already project to be better than last year. His OBP is right on par with last year, his steals are better, but his AVE., and runs are a little down. If he would have stayed in a Pirates uniform, I believe he would have had a 30 HR season with the shorter porch at PNC. Now that he has been traded to Turner Field, his power will go down, but his production will be the same if not better in a much more talented veteran line-up in Atlanta than he was in Pittsburgh. Again, another wait and see...and when he continues with good production, I am going to be the first one to shout "I told ya so!"

J Offord said...

I don't like his comments about leaving Pittsburgh, true as they are. But anyway, I do like the prospect of this lineup:

C Doumit
1B Alvarez
2B Sanchez/Ford
SS Wilson/Friday/D'Arnaugh
3B An. LaRoche
LF G. Hernandez
CF McCutchen
RF Tabata

Ngewo said...

I believe that Gorkeys will be someone the Pirates package with Wilson or Sanchez at the trade deadline in order to get a blue chip pitching prospect...

J Offord said...

True, but they better not trade Wilson...Not until we have a capable SS ready to take over.

Ngewo said...

That might be awhile, it seems like they have not really put any thought into the SS position.

J Offord said...

Agreed. By the way, I really liked what I saw from Morton last night in his 1 inning of work...

Ngewo said...

I think Rocco said that from what he saw, Morton might have the best stuff in the rotation (not saying much, but it is a start...)

J Offord said...

Who is Rocco? My ex-roommate??

Ngewo said...

Rocco DeMaro, from 104.7 (has the show after the games)